Guest Reviews

 

Sullivan County has been enjoying a resurgence as more people visit and find out what a great vacation spot it is. Whether you need a get away for a weekend, or want to spend two weeks or longer, we have the ideal place to create wonderful memories while you relax, or explore and recharge. Here are just a few of the nice things our guests are saying (reviews found on HomeAway.com):

Amazing Family Reunion at the Perfect Place!

5/5 *****

Stayed Jul 2022

Shannon B.
 

For the first time in four years our family could get together with ages ranging from 4 months to 79 and this home was the perfect place to accommodate everyone and make it a very special time. The 2 houses are outfitted extremely well with everything you could imagine needing. The indoor and outdoor spaces are terrific for allowing a large group to all be together as well as having various spots for small groups to enjoy some needed alone time. The beds were all very comfortable, the kitchens have everything that is needed for great meals, the outdoor dining & BBQ area made for a perfect place for all our cooking and meals, and even on the one occasion we had to do dinner indoors the big table in the big house fit all 15 who needed a spot at the table! The host was fantastic and very responsive, answering all our questions very quickly ahead of time and providing easy ways to be in contact throughout our stay. The grounds around the house are beautiful, well-groomed by Lou and we took full advantage of the path around the lake as well as the lake to enjoy the outdoors as much as possible. Fishing was a hit even though it was not something we had planned to do! A visit to the Alpaca farm 3 mins away was well worth it too for the younger ones. The stores are 10 – 15 mins away which is also super convenient for when you have to restock.

We have been doing lake house reunion vacations with my family for almost 10 years now and this was by far the best one ever thanks to this wonderful summer getaway spot! We can’t wait to be back next year.

Published Jul 13, 2022
 
_________________________________________________________________________

Beautiful property for our family reunion!

5/5

Stayed Jun 2022

Stuart W.
 

With spacious accommodations and ample recreation activities with the lake, we couldn’t have found a better spot to get our family together. Our Host Karen was both accommodating and responsive.

Thank you very much and we’ll be back!

Published Jun 27, 2022
 
_________________________________________________________________________
 

Magical place on the lake

5/5 *****

Stayed Aug 2020

Miriam C.

We had a wonderful stay. The property was better than described. The kitchen was easy to make large meals for 4 families. We biked, swam, walked and relaxed. It was the perfect place for a family getaway.

Published Aug 31, 2020

_________________________________________________________________________

Wonderful

5/5 *****

Stayed Jul 2020
Debra A. Long Island, NY
 

Incredibly peaceful setting. We had a great week on the lake. The fishing was excellent and the water was clean and refreshing. The houses were comfortable and well equipped. The owner was a pleasure to deal with. This is a perfect spot to get away from it all and recharge with friends and family.

Published Jul 21, 2020
 
_________________________________________________________________________
 

Amazing. Beautiful. Relaxing.

 
Stayed June 2020
Amy W.
 

We stayed at this beautiful property for 9 days to celebrate my mother’s 90th birthday. It was just beautiful. Everything was clean, well organized, and well prepared for our visit. Karen was extraordinarily helpful and quickly responsive. The lake was amazing — clean, clear, beautiful water. The kitchen was wonderfully and thoughtfully stocked. The beds were comfortable. The living areas were cozy and a great place to congregate. I hope we can keep coming again and again.

Owner’s Response:Amy we are so happy that you and your family had such a wonderful time at our property celebrating your Mom’s birthday. You were a pleasure to have as guests and we hope that you will come back again for another visit. Enjoy the rest of your summer

_________________________________________________________________________

Beautiful property

5/5 *****

Stayed Sep 2019
Chris M.

One of the most relaxing areas in the Catskills. Both farmhouses are immaculately clean, exactly as described. Ten of us enjoyed celebrating at the nearby golf club and in town at Roscoe Beer Co. The lake is stocked and the fire pit was perfect for drinking beers after catching bass and perch. Thanks again!

Published Oct 2, 2019
 

Owner’s Response:We are so happy that you and your friends had such a relaxing weekend and were able to enjoy some of the local attractions. We hope you will come back and stay at our property again.

_________________________________________________________________________

Paradise on the Lake

5/5 *****

Stayed Sep 2019
Denise R. Highland, NY USA

We rented this magical place for a long weekend…There were 8 guys celebrating a bachelor party weekend. We hiked, swam, kayaked, fished, relaxed by a huge bonfire in the evenings and grilled on the huge stone patio. The house is amazing and on the day of poor weather, we played pool, chilled on the glass patio and played some cards and board games. We were absolutely amazed by the peaceful vibe that overtook us here to rejoice in the news of the upcoming wedding and reminisced about our days that have passed. I highly recommend if you’re looking to disconnect with the hustle & bustle of everyday and just want to chill and totally relax and bond with the best of friends or family..this is the perfect place to be…Views were majestic, lake was refreshing, house was totally amazing and the pics could never do it justice…Why wait? Book today and create one of the greatest memories ever…Thanks so much for your gracious hospitality! We just loved it here, and hope to be back soon.

Published Sep 18, 2019
 

Owner’s Response:We are so happy you had such a wonderful weekend celebrating the upcoming wedding. You were a pleasure to have as quests and we look forward to having you back again.

_________________________________________________________________________

REVIEW

5/5 *****

Stayed Jun 2019
Alan W.

THANKS FOR EVERYTHING. IT WAS WAY BETTER THAN EXPECTED, WAY BETTER THAN PICTURES. PERFECT, FULLY EQUIPPED PROPERTY. EVERYONE HAD A GREAT TIME. WE NEVER LEFT PROPERTY. CAUGHT PLENTY OF FISH. KIDS WERE IN A FISH COMA. KAYAKING, HIKIING, FIRE PIT ETC. BEST VACATION IN YEARS. HOPE TO REBOOK. WE TRIED TO LEAVE IT LIKE WHEN WE GOT THERE. HOPE WE DID OK.

Published Jul 2, 2019
 

Owner’s Response:We are so happy that you and your family had such a great time and the kids enjoyed the fishing. You were perfect guests and we look forward to you visiting our property again.

_________________________________________________________________________

Wonderful Get-Away Weekend!

5/5 *****

Stayed Jun 2019
Tim B.

We had a wonderful stay at the Roscoe property. The houses were nicely kept, the kitchen and grill had everything we needed for our group, and the pool table, lake, and lawn were plenty of fun for everyone. Karen was super helpful and clear in communications and made us feel completely welcome. Would definitely book again!

Published Jun 20, 2019
 

Owner’s Response:We are so happy that you and your group had such a great time and we hope to see you again Tim!

_________________________________________________________________________

Excellent Lake Weekend

5/5 *****

Stayed May 2019
Steven S.

I have stayed a this property 3 consecutive years and always have a wonderful time on the lake. The new renovations are a great improvement and added to the overall experience. I love swimming in the lake and taking the kayaks out. My friends and I will surely be back!!

Published May 30, 2019
 

Owner’s Response:We are so happy you enjoyed your stay and liked the new renovations. We look forward to you coming back to visit us again Steven.